Air Platforms

Wedged camera caused UK Voyager aircraft to plummet

19 March 2014
Seven Royal Air Force Voyagers were grounded after an 'incident' involving an aircraft flying from the UK to Afghanistan caused it to plummet several thousand feet. The cause has been identified as the pilot's camera becoming wedged between the armrest and the side-stick. Source: Crown Copyright

A digital single-lens reflex (SLR) camera becoming wedged between the pilot's armrest and side-stick control column caused a UK Royal Air Force Airbus A330-200 Voyager tanker-transport aircraft, en route to Afghanistan, to plummet several thousand feet before making an emergency landing in Turkey, a preliminary investigation has found.

The interim report, which was released by the Military Aviation Authority (MAA) on 17 March, concluded that the 9 February incident involving Voyager ZZ333 occurred when a movement of the captain's left-hand seat moved the armrest forward, which in turn forced the camera into the side-stick control column.

"The flight data recorder and cockpit voice recorder have shown that the captain's side-stick moved ... prior to the event (introducing a sustained, small pitch-down command ...) and again at the onset of the event (introducing a sustained, fully forward pitch-down command). The recorders have also shown that the captain's seat moved ... prior to the event, and at the onset of the event," the report noted.

"The [investigating] panel has found evidence to link the movement of the seat to the movement of the side-stick, in the form of a digital SLR camera obstruction, which was in front of the captain's left armrest and behind the base of the captain's side-stick. Analysis of the camera has confirmed that it was being used ... leading up to the event. Furthermore, forensic analysis of damage to the body of the camera indicates that it experienced a significant compression against the base of the side-stick, consistent with having been jammed between the armrest and the side-stick unit. Crew interviews have corroborated this evidence.

"Simulations have been carried out which have re-created the scenario, which has shown that it is possible for objects to become inadvertently lodged in the space between the armrest and the side-stick, generating an identical pitch-down command to that seen during the incident."

According to the report, this unintended input resulted in the aircraft losing 4,400 feet in 27 seconds, registering a maximum rate-of-descent of approximately 15,000 feet per minute, before the self-protection system initiated a recovery back towards controlled flight. There were nine crew and 189 passengers on board, many of whom suffered minor injuries. The aircraft diverted to Incirlik Airbase in Turkey, with the rest of the fleet of six aircraft being temporarily grounded until the cause was found.

"Given the weight of evidence, the Service Inquiry is confident that the cause of the event was [a result of] human factors. Nevertheless, the inquiry continues to pursue a standard of evidence that will allow other lines of inquiry to be closed across a range of possible causes. In accordance with its terms of reference, the Service Inquiry continues to examine other factors, such as the post-occurrence management of the event, in order to identify any relevant lessons that may enhance air safety," the MAA report concluded.

All UK Voyagers were cleared to resume flight operations on 21 February.



(487 words)
By posting a comment you confirm that you have read and accept our Posting Rules and our Terms of Use of this site.

RELEVANT PROFILE LISTINGS

  • Cessna 800 Citation Longitude

    Type Long-range business jet. Programme Announced, and model and cabin mockup displayed, at EBACE, Geneva, Switzerland, 14 May 2012. First flight due in mid-2016; certification and service entry in late 2017. Will be built in Wichita, Kansas. Wind tunnel testing to confirm performance completed

  • Falcomposite Furio LN 27

    Type Side-by-side sportplane kitbuilt. Programme Design began April 2006; announced August 2006; first flight (ZK-LLG) 6 February 2008; public debut at Tauranga air show, 17 February. US marketing by Scion Aviation of Fort Collins, Colorado. Designed to FAR Pt 23. First FN 27 RG kit (c/n 002)

  • FMV SM3B

    Type Infrared (IR) tow target. Development Towed by a target drone; designed to avoid direct missile hit on the drone. Compatible with MQM-107B (which see), which can carry up to four individual SM3Bs at wingtips or on underwing pylons. Description Airframe Bullet-shaped pod in two parts;

  • FMV SM6

    Type Infrared (IR) tow target. Development Designed in late 1980s as a low-cost target for training with IR-guided missiles, and has since developed into a seven-version family. Description Airframe Bullet-shaped body with four sweptback tailfins indexed in X configuration. Mission payloads

  • FMV SM9A

    Type Tow target. Development Designed as a multiple-choice tow target for development and training involving either infra-red or radar-guided missiles. Modular design permits easy change from one configuration to the other. Description Airframe Cylindrical body with hemispherical nosecone and

ADVERTISEMENT

Industry Links

IHS Jane's is not responsible for the content within or linking from Industry Links pages.
ADVERTISEMENT