Sea Platforms

France wasted EUR200 million on Anglo-French carrier studies

19 February 2014
France wasted EUR214 million on work to launch a joint aircraft carrier programme with the United Kingdom, the French court of auditors has found. Source: DCNS

The French Court of Auditors (Cour des Comptes) has revealed that France spent EUR214 million (USD274 million) on its studies for a potential common Anglo-French aircraft carrier programme, which was eventually abandoned.

In 2006-07 France paid a total of EUR112 million to the United Kingdom as an "entry ticket" to the UK's Carrier Vessel Future (CVF) programme, and a further EUR102 million on contract studies related to industrial co-operation, "with results now unusable", the court's annual report states.

France currently operates a single aircraft carrier, Charles de Gaulle , which is operational only about 65% of the year, due to heavy maintenance requirements on its nuclear power system.

France therefore began discussions with the United Kingdom in 2002 to launch a common programme to share development costs. However, these plans were suspended in 2008 before being cancelled in 2013 by France's military programming law (LPM).

The court describes the EUR112 million entrance fee to the programme as "a pure French financing contribution to the definition phase of the British aircraft carrier programme", while the EUR102 million studies are "considered obsolete", and therefore wasted, given the cancellation of French plans for a second carrier.

The Anglo-French studies looked to create two carriers for the UK Royal Navy, the currently in-build Queen Elizabeth-class, and one for the French Navy. However, according to the Cour des Comptes, the project was compromised from its beginning

First, the schedules for the two nations were different, with France seeking a carrier in 2015, and the UK only in 2020. Second, the requirements for the two nations were very different: short take-off and landing (STOVL) for the UK, and catapult assisted take-off but arrested recovery (CATOBAR) for the French Navy.

Additionally, the savings from the programme were estimated to be worth only about EUR50 million for the French Ministry of Defence. The two country's industrial strategies were also geared towards national shipyards and suppliers. When the UK government formally launched its CVF programme in 2006, the decision to grant the workload to British firms effectively killed the Anglo-French co-operation programme, according to the court's report.



(348 words)
By posting a comment you confirm that you have read and accept our Posting Rules and our Terms of Use of this site.

RELEVANT PROFILE LISTINGS

  • AH-IIA Westland Super Lynx.

    Operational speed: 125 kt (232 km/h). Service ceiling: 12,000 ft (3,650 m). Range: 130 n miles (240 km). Role/Weapon systems: ASW/ASV roles. First batch upgraded in 1994-97 to Super Lynx standard with Mk 3 radar and Racal Kestrel EW suite. Further modifications (2010-15) include installation

  • Amorim do Valle (River) class

    Fleetlist Comment: Three ships transferred from the UK on 31 January 1995. The contract was signed on 18 November 1994. Steel hulled. All minesweeping gear and the 40 mm gun removed on transfer. Used as hydrographic ships. H 35 and H 36 fitted with a stern gantry and second crane amidships for

  • EDCG 1610 class

    Fleetlist Comment: Based at Niteroi. Three similar EDCG-41 craft are to be built at AMRJ, Rio de Janeiro. The first two were laid down in December 2013 and are to be commissioned in 2015. A third craft is to be laid down in 2015.

  • Helibras/Eurocopter EC-725 UH-15 Super Cougar Mk II.

    Operational speed: 175 kt (324 km/h). Service ceiling: 20,000 ft (6,095 m). Range: 463 n miles (857 km). Role/Weapon systems: Contract awarded on 7 September 2009 for 16 aircraft being built by Helibras. Eight aircraft for ASuW and eight for combat SAR, troop transport and utility roles. The

  • High-speed interception craft

    Fleetlist Comment: RIB33SC design by FB Design, Italy. Funded by UN for riverine and coastal patrol in southern Sudan. Craft in UN livery but commissioned in Bangladesh Navy in 2005.

ADVERTISEMENT

Industry Links

IHS Jane's is not responsible for the content within or linking from Industry Links pages.
ADVERTISEMENT